Goodfellas Pizzeria — Where Locals Eat Like Family
- Underboss
- Oct 28
- 4 min read
When you ask around DeBary where to find the best Italian food and pizza in town, you’ll hear one name over and over — Goodfellas. It’s not just a restaurant, it’s a local institution. A place where families gather, friends toast to good times, and visitors quickly feel like regulars.
❤️ What Locals Are Saying
“DELICIOUS! Atmosphere. Service. Food. All excellent. Beautiful inside. Very nice attentive waitress. Awesome bread and butter, salad, pasta dishes and appetizers. Next time I’m trying the pizza!”— Thomas C., Local Guide
“The Hawaiian pizza was on point. Thank you.”— Tomas Lopez
“Amazing service, delicious food, and marvelous atmosphere.”— Carly H.
These aren’t just reviews — they’re reflections of what makes Goodfellas special: consistency, hospitality, and that unmistakable feeling that you’ve just walked into a place where everybody knows your name.
🍝 A Local Favorite with Big Flavor
Every dish that leaves our kitchen is made with pride, passion, and family tradition. Our chefs start with fresh, high-quality ingredients — house-made sauces, hand-stretched dough, and the perfect balance of flavor in every bite.
From our famous pasta dishes and savory entrées to our perfectly baked pizzas topped with the best Italian cheeses, every meal is a celebration of authenticity. And if you’re in the mood for something to sip on, our full bar offers handcrafted cocktails, premium wines, and local favorites to complement your meal perfectly.
The Secret Behind Goodfellas Pizza’s Popularity
So what makes Goodfellas stand out from the rest? Around here, it’s no secret — it’s the heart, tradition, and attention to detail poured into every single dish. From our handcrafted dough to our signature entrées, everything we serve is made with pride and passion.
👨🍳 Handcrafted from Scratch, the Old-Fashioned Way
Our dough isn’t just made — it’s crafted. Fresh every morning, hand-stretched to perfection for that ideal balance between crispy and chewy. The tomato sauce? Made in-house from vine-ripened tomatoes and our own blend of Italian herbs and spices. It’s a recipe passed down and perfected through the years, the way good Italian food should be.
🧀 More Than Just Pizza
Sure, our pizzas have built a loyal following — from the crowd-favorite Goodfellas Special to our crispy Sicilian style — but our menu doesn’t stop there. Guests come back for hearty pasta dishes, baked entrées, seafood, soups, salads, and more. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic like chicken parmigiana or something lighter like a fresh mozzarella and tomato salad, we’ve got you covered.
🌿 Quality Ingredients, Endless Options
From rich cheeses and savory meats to garden-fresh vegetables and specialty toppings, every ingredient that hits your plate is chosen with care. Vegetarian and gluten-free options are available too, because everyone deserves a taste of Goodfellas.
🍷 A Cozy Place to Gather
The atmosphere at Goodfellas is just as memorable as the food — warm lighting, rustic charm, and the aroma of fresh bread baking in the oven. Our staff treats you like family, and whether you’re here for dinner, a date night, or a private event, you’ll always feel at home.
At Goodfellas, it’s not just about making food — it’s about making memories. That’s the real secret behind our success.
How to Make the Most of Your Visit to Goodfellas Pizza
To enjoy the full Goodfellas experience, here are a few insider tips from our regulars and local fans:
Ask About Our Specials: Our chefs love keeping things fresh with rotating specials and seasonal dishes. You never know what Italian favorite might make a surprise appearance!
Explore Beyond Pizza: Sure, our pies are famous — but don’t miss out on the handmade pastas, seafood entrées, and Italian classics that have made us a local favorite for years.
Start with the Favorites: Warm garlic knots, housemade meatballs, and our fresh salads are the perfect start to any meal.
Pair It Right: Enjoy your meal with a glass of wine or one of our handcrafted cocktails from the full bar — the perfect finishing touch to any plate.
Visit During Quieter Hours: For a more relaxed dining experience, stop by on weekday afternoons or early evenings when the pace slows and you can truly savor the moment.
At Goodfellas, we’re all about good food, good company, and that classic Italian hospitality. Every visit feels like you’re part of the family — because here, you are.
Why Locals Keep Coming Back
The loyalty of Goodfellas’ guests isn’t just about the pizza — it’s about everything we bring to the table. Sure, our pies are legendary, but locals know we’re so much more than that. From handcrafted pastas and hearty entrées to fresh seafood, soups, salads, and desserts, there’s something on the menu for everyone.
Here’s why folks keep choosing Goodfellas again and again:
Authentic Italian Variety: From lasagna and chicken parmigiana to shrimp sinatra and tortellini alfredo, every dish is made with passion and tradition.
Consistent Quality: Whether you’re grabbing a pizza to go or dining in for a full meal, every bite delivers the same great flavor and care.
Full Bar: Pair your meal with a glass of wine, a handcrafted cocktail, or an ice-cold beer from our full bar selection.
Friendly Faces: Our team takes pride in knowing our guests by name — you’re not just a customer, you’re family.
Community Pride: We support our local heroes and neighbors. All active law enforcement officers receive a 10% discount with valid ID — our small way of saying thank you for your service.
Comfort and Cleanliness: A warm, inviting space where great food meets genuine hospitality.
Goodfellas isn’t just a pizza joint — it’s a hometown gathering place. A spot where families celebrate, friends reconnect, and everyone leaves full, happy, and ready to come back for more.
Come Taste What DeBary’s Talking About
At Goodfellas, every guest is family. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, a date night, or a private event, you’ll always find good food, good people, and that unmistakable Italian warmth that keeps our locals coming back.
Goodfellas Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant — where every meal feels like home.
For more information or to get in touch, visit goodfellas
Comments